FHA or conventional?The honest comparison.
The two loan types most first-time buyers compare. The differences that matter are not the labels. They are the insurance, the property rules, and what the payment costs over time.
Both can work. They fail differently.
- FHA is government-insured. It commonly allows 3.5 percent down and its mortgage insurance is often permanent for lower-down-payment loans.
- Conventional is not government-insured. It can allow 3 percent down, but private mortgage insurance can usually be removed as equity grows.
The right comparison is total monthly cost, cash needed, and how long the insurance lasts, not which name sounds safer.
- The comparison table
- The property is part of the comparison
- FHA mortgage insurance
- Conventional PMI
- The payment test
- Questions for a lender
- Four myths
- How to lean
- FAQ
- Sources
- Keep going
The comparison table
Program rules change and lenders add their own requirements. Use this as a map of what to compare, not as a set of eligibility rules.
| Feature | FHA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| Rules | ||
| Who insures it | Federal Housing Administration | No government insurance; private investors |
| Money in | ||
| Down payment | Commonly 3.5 percent | Commonly as low as 3 percent |
| Money monthly | ||
| Mortgage insurance | Upfront premium plus annual premium | Private mortgage insurance below 20 percent down |
| Removing insurance | Usually only by refinancing | Usually removable as equity grows |
| Rules | ||
| Credit review | More flexible history in some cases | Often more sensitive to score and reserves |
| Property condition | Minimum property requirements apply, for safety, soundness, and security | Lender and investor guidelines apply, rather than the FHA handbook |
| Seller concessions | Capped by program rules; the cap is set in the purchase contract | Capped, with limits that vary by down payment; the cap is set in the purchase contract |
More on reading the comparison table
Seller concessions are part of closing costs, and the caps differ by program: read the closing-costs guide for how concessions sit alongside the other costs.
The property is part of the comparison
The loan comparison is not only about the borrower. FHA appraisals include minimum property requirements for safety, soundness, and security, so visible condition issues can matter more on a specific house. Conventional loans also require an appraisal, but the condition standards come from the lender and investor guidelines rather than the FHA handbook.
More on property standards
That is why the same house can be a straightforward purchase under one program and a slower one under the other: the appraisal surfaces the condition items, and the program's standards decide what has to be addressed before closing. Ask before making an offer which standards apply to the property you are considering.
FHA mortgage insurance
FHA loans carry two insurance pieces. An upfront premium is commonly financed into the loan, and an annual premium is usually collected monthly as part of the payment.
More on FHA mortgage insurance
- The upfront premium is typically a percentage of the loan amount and is paid once.
- The annual premium is divided into twelve monthly amounts.
- How long the annual premium lasts depends on the original down payment and loan term. With less than 10 percent down, it commonly lasts for the life of the loan.
- Because it can be permanent, the comparison is not just this month's payment. It is the payment several years from now.
FHA lane: with less than 10 percent down, the annual premium commonly lasts for the life of the loan, so the lane runs until the loan is refinanced or replaced. Conventional lane: private mortgage insurance can usually be removed as equity grows, so that lane ends at removal.
Conventional PMI
Private mortgage insurance protects the lender when the down payment is below 20 percent. It is usually paid monthly, though some structures bundle the cost differently.
More on conventional PMI
- Borrowers can generally request removal once the balance reaches about 80 percent of the home value.
- Servicers must generally terminate it automatically at 78 percent of the original value.
- Payment history and, in some cases, an appraisal affect the timing.
- A higher down payment or a shorter loan term changes how quickly that point arrives.
The payment test
Compare three numbers for the same house, not three marketing descriptions:
- Cash to close at the start, including down payment and closing costs.
- Total monthly payment, including taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, and HOA.
- Cost over five and ten years, including how long the mortgage insurance lasts.
Your payment test, on paper
Fill in one column per loan, from your own Loan Estimates. Nothing here is calculated or stored.
Need the monthly figure first? Use the payment calculator, then bring the number back here.
More on the payment test
Then ask which version leaves enough room for reserves. A loan that is cheaper on paper but drains the savings account is not the cheaper choice in practice.
Questions for a lender
What is the total monthly cost?
More on the total monthly cost
Ask for principal, interest, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, and HOA in one number. Then ask which pieces can change.
How long does the insurance last?
More on how long the insurance lasts
On FHA, ask whether the premium can ever drop off. On conventional, ask when removal is possible and what it requires.
What could block this property?
More on what could block this property
FHA condition standards and conventional appraisal rules can both affect a specific house. Ask before making an offer.
What cash do I need beyond the down payment?
More on cash beyond the down payment
Closing costs, prepaids, escrow deposits, and reserves. Ask for the full picture in writing.
What happens if rates or values change?
More on rates or values changing
Ask about refinancing options later, and what would make a future refinance realistic rather than assumed.
Which loan fits my goals?
More on which loan fits your goals
Tell the lender how long you expect to keep the home. The answer often changes which loan type makes sense.
Four myths worth dropping
Myth
"FHA is only for low-income buyers."
FHA is used by buyers at many income levels. It is popular because of its down payment and credit flexibility, not because of a single income bracket.
On the myths page: Myth 10, “FHA loans are only for first-time buyers”
Myth
"FHA appraisals kill deals."
FHA appraisals do look at condition. That can slow a purchase, but it also surfaces problems a buyer would rather know about before closing.
More on mortgage myths
How to lean
These columns describe situations, not eligibility. Read the side that sounds more like yours, then confirm each point with a licensed lender before you decide.
FHA
FHA tends to fit when…
- Cash is tight and credit history is imperfect — ask a licensed lender: how would my cash and credit history be reviewed under FHA?
- Your cash is tight and a down payment commonly as low as 3.5 percent is part of the picture — ask a licensed lender: what down payment would my file be reviewed at?
- Your credit history is imperfect and a more flexible credit review in some cases matters — ask a licensed lender: how would my credit history be reviewed under FHA?
- Paying an upfront premium plus an annual premium, collected monthly, works in your budget — ask a licensed lender: what would both insurance premiums add to my monthly payment?
- Insurance that usually ends only by refinancing is acceptable for your plans — ask a licensed lender: how long would the annual premium last with my down payment, and what would removing it take?
- The property can meet FHA minimum property requirements — ask a licensed lender: does this property meet FHA minimum property requirements?
- Seller concessions capped by program rules still cover what you negotiated — ask a licensed lender: what concession cap applies to my contract?
Conventional
Conventional tends to fit when…
- Your file is stronger and long-term cost matters more than the smallest starting payment — ask a licensed lender: what would the total cost look like over five and ten years?
- A down payment commonly as low as 3 percent works, with private mortgage insurance below 20 percent down — ask a licensed lender: what would private mortgage insurance cost on my file each month?
- Insurance you can usually remove as equity grows matters to you — ask a licensed lender: when could I request removal, and what would it require?
- Your score and reserves can stand up to a credit review that is often more sensitive to both — ask a licensed lender: how do my score and reserves look under conventional review?
- The property fits lender and investor guidelines rather than a program handbook — ask a licensed lender: which condition guidelines would apply to this property?
- Seller concessions capped with limits that vary by down payment still cover what you negotiated — ask a licensed lender: what concession cap applies at my down payment?
Frequently asked
Is FHA better than conventional?
Not in general. FHA can be the better fit when a smaller down payment or a more forgiving credit history matters, while conventional can cost less over time for a stronger file because private mortgage insurance can usually be removed. The total monthly cost and the length of the insurance matter more than the label.
See it in the table: The comparison table
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
It depends on the original loan-to-value and the program rules in place at the time. FHA annual mortgage insurance commonly lasts eleven years when the original down payment was at least ten percent, and for the life of the loan when it was less. A refinance is often how borrowers remove it.
See how it lasts: FHA mortgage insurance
Can conventional mortgage insurance be removed?
Usually yes. On many conventional loans a borrower can request removal once the loan balance reaches about eighty percent of the home value, and the servicer must generally terminate it automatically at seventy-eight percent of the original value. Appraisal and payment history conditions apply.
See how it ends: Conventional PMI
Do FHA loans have stricter property standards?
FHA appraisals include minimum property requirements for safety, soundness, and security, so visible condition issues can matter more. Conventional loans also require an appraisal, but the condition standards come from the lender and investor guidelines rather than the FHA handbook.
See it on a real house: The property is part of the comparison
Which loan has a lower down payment?
FHA commonly allows 3.5 percent down, while many conventional programs allow as little as 3 percent for qualifying buyers. VA and USDA loans can allow no down payment in eligible situations. The lowest down payment is not automatically the lowest total cost.
Run the payment test: The payment test
Are FHA loans only for first-time buyers?
No. FHA is used by buyers at many income levels. It is popular because of its down payment and credit flexibility, not because of a single income bracket.
See the myths: Four myths
What could block a specific property?
FHA condition standards and conventional appraisal rules can both affect a specific house. Ask before making an offer which standards apply to the property you are considering.
Take the questions: Questions for a lender
Does how long I keep the home change which loan fits?
Often, yes. Tell the lender how long you expect to keep the home. Because FHA insurance can last for the life of the loan while conventional PMI can usually be removed, the answer often changes which loan type makes sense.
See how to lean: How to lean
Sources and program rules
The program rules summarized on this page are published by the agencies below. Their current documents are the final word.
More on sources and program rules
Keep going
Ask Kevin a question
Bring the sentence, the estimate, or the number you want a second look at: Kevin@ReadMeMortgage.com · (408) 406-7900
Lending services are in preparation.